The Problem with Home Insurance Fraud and How it Affects You

Welcome to My Personal Finance Journey! If you are new here, please read the “About” or “First-Time Visitor” pages to find out more about us. If you would like to receive free updates on articles like this by email, then sign up here or you can subscribe to the RSS feed. Also, check us out on Twitter or Facebook. Thanks for visiting! Keep on learning!

home insurance fraud insurance fraud homeowner's insurance insurance home buying

Hello everyone! Jacob here with you! I’ve finally emerged from the depths of PhD qualification exam preparation land (just took the test today!) and am ready to put more time in to my blog! I apologize for being a little elusive lately, but hey, life happens! 

To get us started back on the right track, the following is today’s guest post. Enjoy!  

The Problem with Home Insurance Fraud
When it comes to insurance fraud, home insurance is the type of insurance most at risk of fraudulent behavior. The Association of British Insurers has revealed that 335 fraudulent claims are made every day against home insurance, many of them against contents insurance policies.

The Severity of the Issue

This is a serious issue: the fraud costs around £2.3 million (3.67 million USD) every day. Around 50% of all fraudulent insurance claims relate to home insurance, mostly carried out by householders. This is a problem for insurance companies as it is their responsibility to prove when a person making a claim is committing an act of fraud.

Case Studies

Examples of people trying to fraudulently claim on their contents insurance include a man who wanted to claim for DVDs that he said had been stolen, but turned out not to even yet be released in the UK. Unfortunately, this sort of thing is currently all too common.

How Does Home Insurance Fraud Affect You?

The huge cost of home insurance fraud also has a follow-on effect for honest policy holders, meaning that it impacts on everyone. For instance, people are likely to receive higher home insurance quotes to take account of the amount of money currently being lost to fraudulent activity. It is thought that such behaviour adds around £44 to the cost of average home insurance quotes; a significant figure when you consider that the average cost of a policy in the UK is currently around £164. If no fraud existed at all, this figure might well be able to be reduced.
As it is, while home insurance fraud remains a problem, it seems likely that honest policy holders will continue to be impacted on when they get home insurance quotes. Insurers, however, are aware of this and so are stepping up their efforts to stamp out fraud and protect their honest customers to make sure everyone gets a fair deal. 

How about you all? How often do you feel that home insurance fraud occurs? Have you ever known any one in your community that has tried to get away with this type of fraud? What impact do you feel this type of behavior has on the rest of us? 

Share your experiences by commenting below!

Jacob’s Thoughts – Listed below are my random thoughts as I was reading this article.

  • @ Home insurance fraud being the most common type of insurance fraud – 
    • I can definitely imagine that homeowner’s (or real estate in general) insurance fraud is one of the most common forms of insurance fraud out there.
    • Why’s this, you might be asking? In my opinion, I think that the answer lies in that home insurance is a fairly broadly defined coverage, meaning that you define an approximate value of the goods in your house and get a policy to cover those in the case of a fire, tornado, etc. Because there is a significant amount of wiggle room in what’s included, this, in my opinion, motivates people to feel they can “game” the system easier.
  • @ The consequences of home insurance fraud –
    • As mentioned in this article, I think it’s important to point out that home insurance fraud doesn’t just negatively affect the person partaking in the activity if they get caught. 
    • In fact, when the insurance companies have to pay out more money than their complex mathematical algorithms plan, all of the honest insurance policy carriers simply have to pay more to compensate for the monetary loss. 
    • So, I guess what I am getting at here is that it actually benefits us all to watch out for fraud and strongly discourage this behavior. I know I don’t want to pay any more than I have to for my homeowner’s insurance policy! 
  • @ What motivates people to want to partake in home insurance fraud?
    • In writing the comments above, I became interested in thinking about what exactly motivates people to partake in home insurance fraud. Is it greed? Is it desperation for money?
    • While I think that the answer may lie in a mix of the two motivations mentioned above, I really am amazed at how many people think they can get away with insurance fraud, even though the insurance companies undoubtedly have entire departments dedicated to seeking out fraudulent claims.
    • However, enough people must be getting away with this fraud in some shape or form in order for people to continue doing it!

***Photo courtesy of


  1. 20sfinances says:

    It's unfortunate that some ruin it for the majority. If only we could have that money back that was lost to compensating for fraud.
    My recent post Getting Through College Without Student Loans

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge