Google Gmail and Calendar vs. Microsoft Outlook – Which Is Better For Productivity?

————————————————————————————————————————
Welcome to My Personal Finance Journey! If you are new here, please read the “About” or “First-Time Visitor” pages to find out more about us. If you would like to receive free updates on articles like this by email, then sign up here or you can subscribe to the RSS feed. Also, check us out on Twitter or Facebook. Thanks for visiting! Keep on learning!
————————————————————————————————————————

Email, Hamster Revolution, David Allen, Getting Things Done, email management, productivity, Google Calendar, GMail, Outlook, efficiency

It’s pretty amazing to me to think about how much the world’s usage of technology and telecommunication has changed in such a short time since the year 2000. When I graduated high school in 2004, almost nothing related to school was accessed online. The teachers didn’t communicate with students via email, BlackBoard, Collab,  or other online document/course management systems. In fact, I think the only reason I ever used a computer back then was either a) to chat with my friends using AOL Instant Messenger or b) type up reports whenever it was absolutely required! In fact, AOL seemed like it was one of the only popular Internet and email providers.

Now, it’s hard to find people with an AOL email address (I still have one, but all that it receives is about 20 messages of SPAM per day). Furthermore, the AOL service is now free, instead of paying $30 per month like we used to.

My my how times have changed. When I graduated from college in 2008 from the University of Arkansas, I had four email accounts – 1 from college, a Gmail account, a Yahoo account, and my old AOL account. The professors communicated everything via email and online course management systems – from class notes to exam grades and coordinating meetings. I even had started and run an eBay selling business! However, at this time, I still was only checking my email maybe once or twice a day. Why? Because I didn’t seem to receive that many emails.

After college in 2008, I started my first job as an engineer with a large publicly traded pharmaceutical company. It was then that the use of email become very widespread for me, with me having the temptation to constantly check it during the day. In fact, I found myself at times purposely ONLY checking it 2 times during a day in order to maximize productivity (see Getting Things Done by David Allen and The Hamster Revolution for more details on this)

During this time, my eyes were opened to (a new tool for me at least) the Microsoft Outlook email/calendar/task management software. At the company I worked for, nearly everything was managed through Outlook: there was a handy dandy directory in Outlook that told you everyone’s contact info as well as their physical work addresses and supervisors, it was used to reserve rooms for meetings, and was used to manage email.

Since my exposure to Microsoft Outlook 4 years ago now, I have been able to compare Google’s Gmail and Calendar features to Microsoft Outlook head-to-head. As such, the purpose of today’s post is to share some of my thoughts about these two products so that you can determine whether Gmail or Outlook is better for you. 

Comparison of Calendar Capability – Google vs. Outlook

In my opinion, Google’s calendar and Outlook’s calendar are fairly similar – probably because Google modeled their calendar after the features that were tried and testing in Outlook. Below is a summary of the similarities and differences:

Similarities

  • Both allow you to create and schedule events (either one time or recurring), invite attendees, and program reminders as pop-ups on your screen. 
  • Both allow you to share calendars with others. 
  • Both allow you to view your calendar in multiple formats – daily, weekly, etc. 
Differences
  • Google calendar allows you to program email reminders. Also, you can program reminders beyond the maximum 2 weeks allowed in Outlook. 
  • Google calendar also features a “search” capability, making you able to search all of your events.
  • Outlooks allows you to work “offline” more easily than Google does, in my opinion. However, Google does have offline browser apps for Gmail and Calendar now
  • Outlook allows you to drag and drop EMAILS directly from your mail to your calendar. This is very handy for me since it is easy to see what the email chain contained when an event pops up on my calendar. 
  • Next, Outlook’s Calendar content is stored on your computer, not online like Google is. This can be either a plus or minus, depending on how you look at it. 


Verdict – In my opinion, both Google and Outlook’s calendars are good, so I recommend using both. 
However, because I really like the Outlook drag and drop feature, I choose to mainly operate, add, and manage events through Outlook. But, you can easily take advantage of the features of Google’s Calendar by simply using the handy Sync function developed by Google to automatically copy all events between the two programs. 

Comparison of Email Capability – Google vs. Outlook

Overall, I think most would agree that Gmail and Outlook have a very different ‘feel’ when it comes to how each program handles email. On one hand, Gmail is very rapid, and allows for you to shoot off many emails within a minute, while Outlook requires a few more clicks with multiple reply screens needing to pop up, and then you have to click the Send/Receive button to send the email right away. Listed below are some of the similarities and differences between the two programs:

Similarities

  • Of course, both enable the user to send and receive emails, mark the emails as read or unread, and create folders in which to place emails. 
  • Both seem to have good SPAM/Phishing controls, which prevents the automatic downloading of external new content that could potentially harm your computer. 
  • Both allow email notifications on your desktop, if you desire. However, I personally don’t recommend this because it can distract you from the current task you are working on in favor of checking your email. 
  • Both allow you to have a signature below every email you write. However, there are some differences here. See the Outlook section below.
  • Both have Out of Office Notification capability. 
  • Both allow you to send mail using other email addresses that you own/control.
  • Both are ‘searchable,’ meaning that you can search folders for specific words or email addresses. However, as you can imagine, Google is a little better/quicker at this search feature than Outlook I think.  

Differences – Email Features Provided by Gmail

  • Has the Gchat feature, which is good for people wanting to communicate quickly with other people online. Webcam conferencing is also possible with Gmail, as well as calling people on the phone. 
  • Has the “Conversation View” feature, which appends conversations of the same topic within the same window. 
    • Personally, I hate this feature. I am never able to find WHERE in the window the newest email letter is, unless I search for it for about 3 minutes. 
    • The other option to this is to turn off the Conversation View, which is not any better because it doesn’t place old emails in the same chain within the same window, making you unable to view the progression. 
  • Gmail has an auto-forwarding feature, which allows you to automatically have any new messages sent to your account to another account. This is great for enabling you to maintain multiple email accounts, but only having to actually log in to one every day. 
  • With Gmail, all emails are backed up online, away from your local computer. This is a good thing for safety. You also have 10 GB of free storage space, in addition to your Google Document/Drive folder. 

Differences – Email Features Provided by Outlook

  • Unlike Gmail, when you click “reply” on Outlook, it simply copies the text from your current email chain below the new message you are writing. There are no tricks to finding out what order the emails were sent. 
  • Signatures. 
    • Simply put – I love the signatures feature in Outlook. Not only do I have my contact information in my signature, but I also have about 15 common email responses pre-typed in these email signatures that save me loads of time/pain each week. 
    • Gmail does have a somewhat new “Canned Responses” feature that is similar to this in Outlook. However, when I tried it, the canned responses had to be entire previous emails, not just a specific copy/pasted text like in Outlook. I think that Google will eventually improve this, but for now, I found Outlook to be better for this purpose. 
  • Folders.
    • The folder capability in Outlook is extremely flexible and truly maximizes my organization abilities. 
    • First, you can create as many folders as you want, and unlike Gmail (where they are “hidden” and you have to click ‘view more’ through in indiscernably organized list), the folders are very easy to view on the sidebar of the screen. You can view an example of the folders I have set up in the picture below:
   
    • In addition, in each Outlook folder, you can either specify that you’d like to display the total number of items or the total number of unread items. This ‘total number of items’ display feature is especially useful for actionable folders (like the ones with the @ sign shown above) because even though I have already read all of these emails, they still need a response/follow up, so I don’t want to lose sight of them. 
    • Lastly, with Outlook folders, you can drag and drop emails from your inbox in to the proper folders. With Gmail, you have to click a drop down menu and select the destination folder from a somewhat long list. This takes up more time than is necessary in my opinion. 
  • Outlook can connect and download email from web-based email services, such as Gmail and Yahoo, using POP and/or IMAP protocols. 
  • Control How Often You Send/receive Email and Go Offline.
    • Another thing I like about Outlook is that you can specify how often (if ever) that your emails are automatically downloaded. This can be as much as every 30 seconds to every 30 minutes, or never, if you set Outlook as offline. 
    • For me, I only like to read my email several times throughout the day so that I don’t get distracted from being strategic about the order that I tackle things to do. 
    • So, what I do is set Outlook to stay “offline” and just manually send/receive my email when I am ready by pressing the F9 button.  
  • Change Arrangement of Screen Elements.
    • With Outlook, it is very easy to change the orientation of the email reading pane and folders. 
    • For example, I like to have my reading pane on the right side of the screen. However, you can also have it on the left or on the top. 
  • Mark Comments in An Email.
    • Another cool feature of Outlook is that it allows you to (if you desire) automatically mark comments in a previous email in a different color text. This is particularly useful if you are reviewing someone’s proposal or responding to a list of questions posed in a previous email.  

Verdict – In my opinion, for maximizing productivity for folks that receive 50-200 emails per day (not uncommon in today’s working world), Microsoft Outlook is head and shoulders above Gmail because of the customization options available. In particular, the capability that Outlook provides with folders, signatures, and logically appending past email text is much better for people that are short on time.


On the other hand, Google’s Gmail is slightly ‘quicker’ at sending individual emails, and as such, is well suited for people that receive only a couple emails every day and do not need all of the hierarchy of organization with folders, etc. 


In fact, in order to have the benefits of both Gmail and Outlook (email and calendar), I would actually recommend doing what I do and have a Gmail email account/address, but operating all of your email and calendar activities on a day-to-day basis through Outlook. This is very easy to set up using the POP/IMAP downloading and Calendar Sync features discussed in the previous sections. By doing this, you can have the Gchat, auto-forwarding, and online backup of all emails (even ones sent through Outlook) while keeping the organization of Outlook.

How about you all? Do you use Gmail (or another online email provider) or Outlook to manage your email and calendar on a day-to-day basis? Which do you think is better and why? 


Share your experiences by commenting below!

    ***Photo courtesy of http://www.public-domain-image.com/cache/objects-public-domain-images-pictures/electronics-devices-public-domain-images-pictures/computer-components-pictures/black-computer-keyboard_w725_h483.jpg

    Comments

    1. I love Gmail, but one feature it is missing is the “Send Later” or “Send at Specific Time” feature. For example, I would have wanted to send out my Carnival email noticed when the carnival went live at 12:15am. But I'm not going to be up. Instead, I either had to send it prior to going live (which I think is dumb because the link won't work), or well into the morning when I finally have time.

      It is very irritating it doesn't have this feature!
      My recent post 5 Things Not To Spend Money on in College

      • Good call Robert! Seems like that would be a super easy feature to add as well. I just looked, and Outlook does have that feature, but the trick is that you have to have the program open at the time you want to send in order for it to go. Not the best if you are going to bed and want to send an email mid morning.
        My recent post Saving Money on Your Health Insurance

    2. Why so many folders? I think that just creates more confusion. I offer the opposite recommendation…Gmail's searching capability, access from anywhere, conversation threads, filtering, flexibility with add-ons, multiple account capabilities, “unlimited” storage, etc. is much more suited for those of us who receive “100's” per day. Have you really sat down and gone through all of the functionality with Gmail? Almost all of your points of “can do in Outlook vs can not do in Gmail” are incorrect. For instance, Gmail does allow you to drag emails into folders (labels). I have been using outlook for years (company requires it through exchange) but after using Gmail personally and through another business, I would dump Outlook in a heartbeat. Plus, the mobile options for Gmail, synching unread/read, etc. is very useful and easy to configure.

      • Thomas L says:

        If you have hundreds of email with similar content, the folders in Outlook are the only way to go as people can organize them very well. The search function in GMail is useless as you get hundreds if not thousands of messages (for business) and you need to scan them carefully for the content you want. GMail may be good for the casual e-mailer or one where topics and contacts vary more than depth of topic. For business Outlook wins hands down and it is not even close. 2 companies i have been associated with switched to Gamil and found the loss of productivity to be incredible.

    Speak Your Mind

    *

    CommentLuv badge