Welcome to My Personal Finance Journey! If you are new here, please read the “About” or “First-Time Visitor” pages to find out more about us. If you would like to receive free updates on articles like this by email, then sign up here or you can subscribe to the RSS feed. Also, check us out on Twitter or Facebook. Thanks for visiting! Keep on learning!
During a recent trip to Raleigh, North Carolina, I went to use the bathroom of the restaurant at which my family and I were having lunch. In this restaurant’s bathroom, they had both a hand dryer AND a paper towel dispenser! I was like, “Wow, I guess they couldn’t make up their minds about which method people might like more!”
As a result of this experience, it got me wondering how paper towels and hand dryers stack up against each other when it comes to both the following aspects:
- Which is more popular among consumers?
- Which is cheaper and has a lower amount of environmental impact?
- Which is more effective at drying and being sanitary?
In today’s post, we’ll explore these questions and try to find some answers! Let’s get started!
Are Hand Dryers or Paper Towels More Popular?
In order to get started answering this question, I first wanted to know which one of our two ‘bathroom drying competitors’ is more popular, among bathroom providers stocking them and also as far as favorites among customers.
The answer to this was very unanimous in that every source I could find stated that paper towels were much more popular among customers and also among janitorial services that service and provide bathrooms.
- A 2008 study of European consumers cited by Wikipedia stated that 63% of respondents preferred paper towels over hand dryers (only 28% of respondents preferred hand dryers).
- This trend of consumers preferring paper towels over hand dryers was also confirmed by studies reported by Livestrong.com and Kimberly-Clark stating the 55% and 87% of consumers surveyed, respectively, preferred paper towels over the “other” electrical option.
- Janitorial service companies prefer to stock their bathrooms with paper towels since this provides them with more billable man-hours to clean and restock the restrooms they service.
Which is Cheaper and More Environmentally-Friendly?
Contrary to the results of the previous question on popularity, hand dryers clearly reign supreme in the categories of cost-effectiveness and environmental responsibility.
- A 2011 Guardian report stated that paper towels generate a total of 70% more carbon emissions over their lifetime compared to the newest cold-air dryer technologies (Dyson Blade, etc).
- A Rodale report stated that even though the initial capital costs for a hand dryer is higher ($300-$400 versus $20-$30 for a paper towel dispenser), the increased operating costs for paper towels over electric hand dryers makes the latter more cost effective in the long-run.
- For example, paper towels cost $23 per 1,000 uses to refill. On the other hand, electric hand dryers only cost $1.47 per 1000 uses for the electricity.
- In addition, it was reported that hand dryers often last 10 years before replacement is needed and require virtually no maintenance to keep running.
Which is More Effective at Drying?
Which is Better for Personal Hygiene?
- For example, a 2008 study by the University of Westminster found that paper towels were clearly better at reducing the amount of bacteria on one’s hands by a full 200% over hand dryers.
- However, it was pointed out that this study was funded by the paper supply companies, and as such, the results may not be all that reliable due to the conflict of interest.
- On the other hand, a 2000 study by the Mayo Clinic found no statistical difference between the contamination on one’s hands after using paper towels or hand dryers after washing your hands.
Because of these conflicting results, it’s hard to tell whether one method is superior to the other for cleanliness.
So, Are Paper Towels or Hand Dryers Better Overall?
From this investigation, we saw that paper towels are both more popular and more effective for drying consumers’ hands. However, hand dryers are cheaper, better for the Earth, and possess about the same level of hygiene.
As such, I think that if I were a business owner, I would insist on installing a high-powered (new technology) hand dryer and NOT having paper towels since paper towels simply drive up my costs.
Even if my customers didn’t prefer the hand dryer to paper towels, I doubt that alone would be enough to prevent them from doing business with me.
How about you all? Do you like paper towels or a hand dryer better for drying your hands?
If you had a business, which would you install for your customers to use?
Share your experiences by commenting below!
***Photo courtesy of http://www.flickr.com/photos/marktee/6009596457/sizes/l/in/photostream/